Migrant worker protection - Buffalo News Editorial
Guilty pleas highlight lack of progress on civil rights for transient farm labor

12/6/2004

Recent guilty pleas by a 53-year-old Texas woman and three family members are a step in extending civil rights protections to migrant farm workers, but by no means do they mark an end to this issue.

New York State still has a long way to go in remedying abuses of migrant farm workers. A Farm Worker Fair Labor Practices Act, giving agricultural workers the same rights that all other workers in the state already enjoy, passed the Assembly but was bottled up in committee by the Senate. That bill would give migrants the right to overtime pay, the right to a day of rest, disability insurance and the right to bargain collectively.

Until this act is passed by the Legislature, farm workers will be open to treatment akin to slavery. The 80,000 to 100,000 people hired each year to do seasonal harvesting work - a job farmers can't easily find local workers willing to do - are important to the agriculture industry. But the majority of farmers who treat workers well are being tainted by the abuses by a few labor contractors whose misdeeds threaten the entire practice.

Guilty pleas by Maria Garcia and her relatives, Texans who ran labor camps in Genesee and Orleans counties, highlight one such case and amounted to the first local test of a federal law passed in 2000 to protect illegal aliens. Prosecutors said as many as 50 migrant farm workers were crammed into one house, sharing a single bathroom. Worse, there were times when there was not enough food for everyone.